| 英国19世紀の女性の解放運動の高まりは大きなインパクトを社会に与え、その反動とあいてフェミニズム運動を
攻撃する多くの言説が発表されます。エディション・シナプスではこの時代の英国反フェミニズム文献を系統的
に復刻集成してまいりましたが、シリーズ第3回では、雑誌記事やパンフレットを集めます。女性運動と異な
り、反フェミニストは一部の反女性参政権運動を除くと組織的な活動をとらなかったため、その著作、言論など
も特定の機関誌・紙によらず、非常に多様な出版媒体において行われました。このため、これらの文献を系統的
に集め、歴史研究の資料として活用することには、今まで大変な困難が伴ってきました。
本コレクションは、19世紀英国の主要評論誌や諷刺雑誌だけでなく、入手、閲覧の極めて難しい大衆雑誌やパン
フレット類なども対象に、19世半ばから1920年代前半までの記事80件強を復刻にて収録します。内容は11のテーマに分類され、教育、法律、科学、職業、結婚、母と家庭、社会諷刺、レジャー、文学、参政権、モダニズム、
戦争など、現代の女性史研究に必要な視点がすべて網羅されています。
フェミニズム運動が同時代の政治、社会、世論に与えた影響を精査し、新たに女性史研究を展開させるための一次資料として、どうぞ広くご活用ください。
●収録予定文献（編集の都合での変更の可能性がございます。）●
1) Education, Law and Science
‘Lectures to Ladies on Practical Subjects,’ Saturday Review (15 December 1855)
‘Law for Ladies,’ Saturday Review (24 May 1856)
‘The Over-Education of Women’ Saturday Review (8 May 1858)
‘The Intellect of Women,’ Saturday Review (8 October 1859)
‘Political Establishment for Young Ladies, 'Punch (6 June 1868)
‘Women Graduates,’ Saturday Review (5 July 1873)
Henry Maudsley, ‘Sex in Mind and in Education,’ Fortnightly Review (1 April 1874)
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Higher Education of Woman,’ Fortnightly Review (October 1886)
Lombroso, Cesare, The Physical Insensibility of Woman, Fortnightly Review, 1892
Bertha J Johnson, ‘University Degrees for Women: The Case Against,’ The Humanitarian (1896)
Women at Oxford and Cambridge, The Quarterly Review, Oct 1897
2) Working and Professional Women
‘Female Labour,’ Fraser’s Magazine (March 1860)
[W.R. Greg], ‘Why are Women Redundant?’ National Review (April 1862)
S H Swinny, Where women are the wage-earners: Life and Labour in Dundee, The Positivist Review, 1
June 1906
Women and Work, The Saturday Review, Dec 28 1907
Married Women and the Factory Law, Anti-Suffrage League pamphlet series, 1909
Janet E Courtney, The Prospects of Women as Brain Workers, The Nineteenth Century and After, Nov
1913
3) Marriage, Motherhood and Domesticity
[Eliza Lynn Linton] ‘Rights and Wrongs of Women,’ Household Words (1 April 1854)
‘Man’s Might and Woman’s Right,’ Saturday Review (3 May 1856)
‘Wives,’ Saturday Review (19 December 1863)
Arabella Kenealy, ‘A New View of the Surplus of Women’, Westminster Review, 1891
Dixon, Ella Hepworth, Why Women are Ceasing to Marry, The Humanitarian, 18 Oct 1894
Arabella Kenealy, ‘The Dignity of Love’, The Humanitarian, 1896
St George Mivart, ‘The Degradation of Woman,’ The Humanitarian (1896)
Frant Allen, ‘Is it Degradation?’ The Humanitarian (1896)
Arabella Kenealy, ‘The Dignity of Love,’ The Humanitarian (1896)
Edith Ellis, The Maternal in Politics, Anti-Suffrage Review, 1911, p. 1
WCD and Catherine Whetham, Decadence and Civilisation, The Hibbert Journal, vol x no 1, Oct 1911
Helen Hamilton, Spinsters in the Making - Types 1.- The College Woman, The Freewoman, 14 Dec 1911
Leonora Lockhart, At the Cross-Roads, Anti-Suffrage Review, 1912
Frances H Low, Why we Oppose Women Suffrage, The New Age, March 1913
Ethel Colquhoun, The Superfluous Woman: Her Cause and Cure, Nineteenth Century and After, 75, March
1914
Feminism and Depopulation, Anti-Suffrage Review, 1917
4) Satire
John Leech, ‘Bloomeriana,’ Punch cartoons (1851)
‘Bloomerism,’ Punch (1851, p. 217).
‘A Poser for a Bloomer,’ Punch cartoon (1851, p. 208)
‘Bloomerism,’ Punch cartoon (1851, p. 189)
‘Bloomerism -An American Custom,’ Punch cartoon (1851)
‘A Probable Incident if That Bloomerism isn’t put down,’ Punch cartoon (1851)
‘One of the Delightful Results of Bloomerism,’ Punch (1851, p. 192)
‘Sucking Pigs,’ Household Words (8 November 1851)
‘The Ladies of Creation; or, How I was cured of being a strong-minded woman,’ Punch cartoon
(Punch’s Almanac for 1853)
‘The Parliamentary Female,’ ‘Mary Protecting the Weaker Sex,’ ‘The Band at St James’s
Palace,’ and ‘The Woman at the Wheel,’ ‘Efficiency of Female Police Force in what is vulgarly
called a “Jolly Row”,’ Punch cartoons from ‘The Ladies of the Creation’ (1853)
[Eliza Lynn Linton], ‘Passing faces,’ Household Words (14 April 1855)
‘A gentleman of Influence,’ Punch cartoon (22 July 1865)
‘Probably the Next Absurdity,’ Punch cartoon (18 January 1868)
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Girl of the Period,’ Saturday Review (14 March 1868)
‘Mrs. Punch’s Letters to Her Daughter,’ Punch (4 July 1868)
‘Is Woman a Human Being and Immortal?’ Saturday Review (7 November 1868)
‘What it will soon come to,’ Punch cartoon (24 February 1894)
‘Donna Quixote,’ Punch cartoon and poem (28 April 1894)
‘Passionate Female Literary Types,’ Punch cartoon (2 June 1894)
‘The Weaker Sex,’ Punch cartoon (20 March 1907)
Our Suffragists, Punch, (March 20 1907)
The Storming of the Bastille, Anti-Suffrage Review, August 1912
A A Milne, Cross-Examining a Suffragist, Punch, 20 Feb 1907
Woman, woman everywhere, Punch, 13 March 1907
Edmund B D'Auvergne, The Brawling Brotherhood, The New Age, 1908
W H Mallock, Women in Parliament, Nineteenth Century and After, July 1912
5) Social Change and Leisure
[T.H. Lister], ‘Rights and Condition of Women,’ Edinburgh Review (April 1841)
[Coventry Patmore], ‘The Social Position of Woman,’ North British Review (1851)
‘Woman’s Emancipation,’ Punch (July 1851, p. 2)
‘Lecture at the Strong-Minded Women’s Club,’ Punch (1852: p. 170-3)
‘A Fear for the Future,’ Fraser’s Magazine (February 1859)
‘A Word to Women,’ Temple Bar (April 1861)
‘Ideal Women,’ Saturday Review (9 May 1868)
Anne Mozley, ‘Clever Women,’ Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine (October 1868)
[Margaret Oliphant}, ‘Mr. Mill on the Subjection of Women,’ Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine
(September 1869)
[Eliza Lynn Linton], ‘The Modern Revolt,’ Macmillan’s Magazine (December 1870)
Eliza Lynn Linton ‘Modern Man-Haters’., Saturday Review, 29 April 1871
M.F. Cusack, ‘Woman’s Place in the Economy of Creation,’ Fraser’s Magazine (February 1874)
[Margaret Oliphant], ‘The Grievances of Women,’ Fraser’s Magazine (May 1880)
Eliza Lynn Linton, Ourselves: Essays on Women, (1884)
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Future Supremacy of Women,’ The National Review (September 1886)
Glennie, J S Stuart, The Proposed Subordination of Men, Fortnightly Review, (1889)
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Characteristics of English Women,’ Fortnightly Review (February 1889)
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Threatened Abdication of Man,’ National Review (July 1889)
Mary Jeune, ‘Women of To-day, Yesterday, and To-morrow,’ National Review (December 1889)
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Judicial Shock to Marriage’., Nineteenth Century, 1891
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Wild Women as Social Insurgents’ Nineteenth Century, 1891
Eliza Lynn Linton ‘The Wild Women, No.1: As Politicians’ Nineteenth Century, 1891
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘The Partisans of the Wild Women’, Nineteenth Century, 1892
Eliza Lynn Linton, ‘A Picture of the Past,’ Nineteenth Century (November 1892)
Ellen Gosse, ‘The Tyranny of Woman,’ New Review (May 1894)
‘Manners and Customs,’ Punch (19 May 1894), p. 229
Arabella Kenealy, Woman as an Athlete, Nineteeth Century, April 1899
Arabella Kenealy, ‘Woman as an Athlete: A Rejoinder’, Nineteenth Century, 1899
Pearson, Karl, 'The Woman Question' and 'Socialism and Sex', The Ethic of Freethought and Other
Addresses, 1901 (2nd ed)
H B Marriot Watson, The Deleterious Effect of Americanisation Upon Women, Nineteenth Century, Nov
1903
George Barlow, The Fall of Woman, Contemporary Review, July 1906
S H Swinny, review of 'The Freedom of Women' by Ethel B Harrison, The Positivist Review, 1 July 1908
H E Hamilton King, Civil War - Want of Cohesion Among Women, Anti-Suffrage Review, 1909
Marjorie Bowen, On Nunneries, Anti-Suffrage Review, 1909
Harold Owen, Man, Woman and Nature, Westminster Review, 1910
Filson Young, The Women's Achievement, The Saturday Review, 9 March 1912
Ethel Colquhoun, Woman and Morality, Nineteenth Century and After, 75, Jan 1914
6) Literature
Eliot, George, Silly Novels by Lady Novelists, Westminster Review, 1856
Allen, Grant, ‘Plain Words on the Woman Question.’, Fortnightly Review, 1889
Allen, Grant, ‘Is It Degradation? (A reply to Professor Mirvart)’., The Humanitarian, 1896
[William Barry], ‘The Strike of a Sex,’ Quarterly Review (October 1894)
J. Peyton, ‘The Modern Malignant: II: The Malignant in Literature,’ The Humanitarian (1896)
Margaret Oliphant, ‘The Anti-Marriage League,’ Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine (January 1896)
Peyton, Y, The Modern Malignant II: In Fiction, The Humanitarian, 1896
Hugh E.N. Stutfield, ‘The Psychology of Feminism,’ Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine (January 1897)
Philip Thomas, The Sins of Ann Veronica, The Positivist Review, 1 March 1910
W J Ferrar, On Women Poets, The Nineteenth Century and After, Oct 1922
7) Anti-Suffragists
[Margaret Oliphant].‘The Great Unrepresented,’ Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine (September 1866)
‘Mill’s Logic: or, Franchise for the Ladies,’ Punch cartoon (30 March 1867)
[Margaret Oliphant], ‘Mill on the Subjection of Women,’ Edinburgh Review (October 1869)
‘Women Voters,’ Saturday Review (3 May 1873)
‘Women,’ Saturday Review (11 April 1874)
Goldwin Smith, ‘Female Suffrage,’ Macmillan’s Magazine (June 1874)
‘Women’s Suffrage,’ Saturday Review (14 July 1883)
Henry Cecil Raikes, ‘Women’s Suffrage,’ National Review (January 1885)
Goldwin Smith, ‘Conservatism and Female Suffrage,’ The National Review (February 1888)
‘The Women’s Protest against Women’s Suffrage,’ The Spectator (1 June 1889)
Charles Selby Oakley, Of Women in Assemblies, Nineteenth Century, Oct 1896
Frances H Low, A Woman's Criticism of the Women's Congress, Nineteenth Century, Aug 1899
Caroline E Stephen, Women and Politics, Nineteenth Century, Feb 1907
‘One Man One Suffragette,’ Punch cartoon (13 March 1907)
Simon, Mrs. E M, Women's Suffrage: Some Sociological Reasons for Opposing the Movement, pamphlet
(1907)
Edith M. Massie, ‘A Woman’s Plea against Woman Suffrage,’ Nineteenth Century (March 1908)
Women and the Franchise, Edinburgh Review, (July 1908)
Mary A Ward, The Women's Anti-Suffrage Movement, Nineteenth Century, 64, (August 1908)
Mary Maxse, Votes for Women, The National Review, (Nov 1908)
Ethel B Harrison, The Freedom of Women: An argument against the proposed extension of the suffrage
to women. pamphlet (1908)
Mary Ward, Is Woman Suffrage Inevitable?, Anti-Suffrage League pamphlet series, (1908)
A Letter to Mr. Heitland, Anti-Suffrage League pamphlet series, (1908)
Queen Victoria and Women's Rights, Anti-Suffrage League pamphlet, (1908)
Nature's Reason Against Woman Suffrage, Anti-Suffrage League pamphlet series, (1908)
A M Lovat (Lady), Women and the Suffrage, Nineteenth Century, (July 1908)
M E Simkins, Suffrage and Anti-suffrage - a woman worker's appeal, The National Review, (Jan 1909)
A V Dicey, Woman Suffrage, The Quarterly Review, (Jan 1909)
T.Dundas Pillans, Plain Truths about Woman Suffrage, pamphlet (1909)
Girton Review, Anti Suffrage League meeting reports, (1909 and 1910)
Bi-Sexual Suffrage, The Saturday Review, (25 June 1910)
The Suffrage Debate, Spectator, (July 16 1910)
Ethel Harrison, Pageantry and Politics, Nineteenth Century, (Aug 1910)
Octavia Hill, Women and the Suffrage, Anti-Suffrage League pamphlet series, (1910)
The Anti-Suffrage Outdoor Campaign, Anti-Suffrage Review, (August 1910)
H.B. Samuels, Woman Suffrage: Its Dangers and Delusions, pamphlet (1910)
Norman, C H, Economic Criticism of Woman Suffrage, Westminster Review, (Jan 1911)
Votes for Ladies, The Eye Witness, (June 22 1911)
The Women's Bill, The Saturday Review, (30 March 1912)
The Ladies' Raid, The Eye Witness, (7 March 1912)
‘JKP’, A Certain Woman, The Eye Witness, (16 May 1912)
A Leap-year Proposal, Anti-Suffrage Review, (May 1912)
Desperate Cases and Desperate Remedies, Anti-Suffrage Review, (May 1912)
Edith Sellers, Where Women Sit in Parliament, Nineteenth Century and After, (July 1912)
Unmasked, Anti-Suffrage Review, (Sept 1912)
Gronno, Arthur Charles, The Woman MP: A Peril to the Country, (pamphlet, undated, Manchester Branch
of the Women's National Anti-Suffrage League)
The Anti-Suffrage Handbook of Facts, Statistics and Quotations for the Use of Speakers, Campaigns
Committee of the National League for Opposing Woman Suffrage, (1912)
Whey Women SHOULD NOT have the Vote: From Woman's Point of View, The Pall Mall Magazine, ( March
1913)
8) Feminism and Militancy
A Woman's Rights Organ, The Saturday Review, Jan 2 1869
E Wake Cook, Anti-Feminism, The New Age, 28 March 1908
Belfort Bax, Feminism and Female Suffrage, The New Age, 30 May 1908
Millicent Murby, The True Gospel of Feminism: A reply to Mr. Belfort Bax, The New Age, 6 June 1908
Belfort Bax, Mr. Belfort Bax Replies to his Critics, The New Age, 8 Aug 1908
Stephen Reynolds, 'Seems So' - The Suffragettes, The Spectator, Feb 1909
Ethel Harrison, Then and Now, Nineteenth Century, 66, Dec 1909
Beatrix Tracy, Is the New Woman Helping Woman?, The National Review, Vol 55 no 328, June 1910.
Author of 'An English-woman's Home', Feminine Versus Feminist, Living Age, 1912
Correspondences on the Suffragettes, The Eye Witness, 21 March 1912
The Suffragette's Dream, Anti-Suffrage Review, April 1912
Young, Filson, Suffragette Island, The Saturday Review, 7 Dec 1912
Arch. Gibbs, The Fraud of Feminism, The New Age, 4 Dec 1912
Arch. Gibbs, The Need for Anti-feminist Action, New Age, 19 Dec 1912
Walter Lennard, The Soul of a Suffragette, Fortnightly Review, April 1913
Father Day, The Feminist Movement, The Anti-Suffrage Review, 1913
Ethel Colquhoun, Modern Feminism and Sex Antagonism, Quarterly Review, July 1913
By Favour of the Militants, Punch, March 2 1913
T Marchant, Feminism, The New Age, 1 May 1913
Phillips, Mrs. Walter Alison (Catherine B. Sennett), Review of books by Colquhoun, Bax, Swanwick,
Hutchins Times Literary Supplement, Feb 5 1914
9) Constructive and ‘modern’ anti-feminism
‘A Woman’s Thoughts about Women’ [Mulock] Saturday Review (10 April 1858)
A Methodist Argument Against the Emancipation of Women, Englishwoman's Review, April 15 1889
Simon, Mrs. E M, Positive Principles for Anti-Suffragists, (pamphlet 1908)
C H Norman, The Injustice of Votes for Women, The New Age, July 18 1908
Caroline E Stephen, The Representation of Women: A Consultative Chamber of Women, Nineteenth
Century, Dec 1908
Beatrice Tina (‘Beatrice Hastings’), The Case of the Anti-Feminists, The New Age, 1908
E Nesbit, Beatrice Tina and the Almighty, The New Age, July 4 1908
Beatrice Tina, Woman's Worst Enemy: Woman, The New Age Press (pamphlet), 1909
Violet Markham, A Proposed Woman's Council, The National Review, Aug 1910
Lewis, Arthur D, The Unimportance of the Women's Movement, The Freewoman, Jan 11 1912
Austin Harrison, The New Sesame and Lilies, The English Review, Feb 1912
Cicely Hamilton, Man, The English Review, April 1912
Homunculus [Austin Harrison?], Woman: A Reply to Man, The English Review, May 1912
May Sinclair, A Defense of Men, The English Review, July 1912
A R Orage, Notes of the Week, The New Age, Aug 22 1912
Responses to Orage's notes of the week, The New Age, 12 Sept 1912
Norman, C H, Will Men Govern when Women have the Vote?, The Freewoman, Sept 5 1912
A R Orage, Notes of the Week, The New Age, 8 May 1913
J M Kennedy, Women and the Caucus, The New Age, 8 May 1913
S M Mitra, Voice for Women - Without Votes, The Nineteenth Century and After, Nov 1913
Violet Markham, ‘Anti Suffrage’, chapter from Return Passage, 1953
10) War
To Rule or to Serve?, Anti-Suffrage Review, June 1915
Patriotism - at a Price, Anti-Suffrage Review, July 1916
Edith Milner, Woman's Place, Anti-Suffrage Review, Jan 1916
Votes for Women with Half the Men Away Anti-Suffrage Review, June 1917
Phillips, Mrs. Walter Alison (Catherine B. Sennett) 'War and Militancy' review of books, Times
Literary Supplement, 16 August 1917
Personal statements on suffrage and war, from A V Dicey, Mary Ward, Harold Owen, John Massie, Gladys
Pott, Heber Hart, Anti-Suffrage Review, Dec 1917
Mary Ward, Let Women Say! An Appeal to the House of Lords, The Nineteenth Century and After, Jan
1918
Woman Suffrage, Anti-Suffrage Review, Feb 1918
Edith Sellers, Boy and Girl War Products, Nineteenth Century and After, Oct 1918
11) After Suffrage
Epilogue, Anti-Suffrage Review, April 1918
A Skilled Labourer, Female Intemperance, Quarterly Review, Jan 1920
Edith Sellers, An Unknown Quantity: The Woman Voter, The Nineteenth Century, March 1922
Edith Sellers, The Manufacture of Girl-Loafers, The National Review, Sept 1921
Edith Sellers, ‘Women Electors and Foreign Affairs’ The National Review, Sept 1922
W J Ferrar, On Women Poets, The Nineteenth Century and After, Oct 1922
Edith Sellers, The Voteless Women of France, The National Review, Aug 1924
●シリーズ既刊●
英国反フェミニズム文献集成 第1回配本
『反フェミニズム：ヴィクトリア朝時代小説選集』全６巻
ANTI-FEMINISM IN THE VICTORIAN NOVEL
編集・解説： Dr Ann Heilmann, University of Wales Swansea
2003年12月刊行
本体セット価￥112,500-
ISBN 4-901481-36-3
http://www.aplink.co.jp/synapse/4-901481-36-3.htm
英国反フェミニズム文献集成第２回配本
『２０世紀初頭の反フェミニズム文献』全6巻
ANTI-FEMINISM IN EDWARDIAN LITERATURE
編集・解説：Lucy Delap, University of Cambridge & Ann Heilmann, University of Wales, Swansea
2006年2月刊行
本体価格￥128,000
約2,200頁
ISBN 4-901481-88-6
http://www.aplink.co.jp/synapse/4-901481-88-6.htm |
